Stafford38/Characteristic/CanonicalGabberInvolutivityInterface.lean

This project (Stafford38) · 1029fdb382eee06e7b59bcf32801f40931e2079a

1 module
2 public import Stafford38.Characteristic.CanonicalResidueExtensionSymbolControlAdapter
3 public import Stafford38.Characteristic.PaperLocalizedInvolutivity
4 public import Stafford38.Characteristic.RadicalMinimalPrimeInvolutivity
5 
6 @[expose] public section
7 
8 /-!
9 # Lane B: the residue-extension input reduced to the cited Gabber theorem
10 
11 The adapter
12 `Stafford38.Characteristic.CanonicalResidueExtensionSymbolControlAdapter`
13 already reduces `CanonicalResidueExtensionSymbolControl` to
14 `CanonicalMinimalPrimeInvolutivityOverFields`: involutivity of every minimal
15 prime of the order initial ideal of the *canonical* quotient, over an
16 arbitrary characteristic-zero field, with no scalar extension, algebraic
17 closure, or Laurent series in the statement.  Two gaps remained between that
18 proposition and the literature theorem it is supposed to instantiate.
19 
20 * Gabber's theorem is about the radical `√Ann_S gr M`, not about the
21   individual minimal primes of `Ann_S gr M`.
22 * Gabber's theorem is about an arbitrary finitely generated filtered module,
23   so neither `0 < N` nor `IsPBWMonicAt` plays any role in it; the canonical
24   right ideal `dA + x₀^N dA` is one instance among all right ideals.
25 
26 This file closes both.  `WeylAssociatedGradedRadicalInvolutivity` is the
27 citation itself, stated for the repository's actual associated graded object:
28 for every characteristic-zero field `L`, every `A_m(L)`, and every right ideal
29 `I`, the radical of `Ann_{S} gr(A/I)` is involutive.  It is *intended* to
30 transcribe the algebraic form of Gabber's theorem proved for
31 almost-commutative `ℚ`-algebras with Noetherian associated graded
32 (Singh--Kumar, *On the Involutivity of the Characteristic Variety*,
33 Comm. Algebra 42 (2014), no. 8, 3607-3618, Theorem 5.1 with Theorems 4.1 and
34 4.2).
35 Two things make that transcription plausible: `A/I` is cyclic, so its
36 order-quotient filtration is good; and the right-module convention costs
37 nothing, because `A/I` is a left `Aᵒᵖ`-module, `gr(Aᵒᵖ) ≅ (gr A)ᵒᵖ = S` since
38 `S` is commutative, and the induced bracket only changes sign.
39 
40 The correspondence with the cited theorem rests on the repository's
41 own identification of `OrderAssociatedGradedModule` with `gr(A/I)` for the
42 differential-order filtration.
43 
44 The chain proved here is
45 `WeylAssociatedGradedRadicalInvolutivity →`
46 `WeylOrderInitialRadicalInvolutivity →`
47 `RightWeylMinimalPrimeInvolutivity →`
48 `CanonicalMinimalPrimeInvolutivityOverFields →`
49 `CanonicalBaseRelativePoissonOverFields →`
50 `CanonicalResidueExtensionSymbolControl`,
51 every step trust-zero.  No Gabber-type statement is proved here; the first
52 proposition is a theorem-shaped interface a caller must still supply.
53 -/
54 
55 namespace Stafford38.Characteristic.CanonicalGabberInvolutivityInterface
56 
57 open Stafford38
58 open Stafford38.CanonicalSupportVanishingReduction
59 open Stafford38.Characteristic
60 open Stafford38.Characteristic.CanonicalResidueExtensionSymbolControlAdapter
61 open Stafford38.Characteristic.PostScalarExtensionPoisson
62 open Stafford38.Characteristic.PaperLocalizedInvolutivity
63 open Stafford38.Characteristic.RadicalMinimalPrimeInvolutivity
64 open Stafford38.CharacteristicAssociatedGradedModule
65 open Stafford38.CharacteristicInitialIdeal
66 open Stafford38.EulerSurjectivity
67 open Stafford38.Geometry.CanonicalResidueExtensionAssembly
68 open Stafford38.WeylEulerResidue
69 open Stafford38.WeylIteratedEquivalence
70 open Stafford38.WeylPBWMonicBridge
71 
72 noncomputable section
73 
74 universe u
75 
76 /-- **The cited Gabber theorem, stated on the repository's own associated
77 graded module.**  For every characteristic-zero field `L`, every Weyl algebra
78 `A_m(L)` with its differential-order filtration, and every right ideal `I`,
79 the radical of the annihilator of `gr(A/I)` is involutive.
80 
81 `A/I` is cyclic, so its quotient filtration is good; this is therefore the
82 statement of Gabber involutivity, not a project-specific strengthening of it.
83 It is a theorem-shaped interface: no proof is asserted here. -/
84 def WeylAssociatedGradedRadicalInvolutivity : Prop :=
85   ∀ (L : Type u) [Field L] [CharZero L] (m : ℕ)
86     (I : RightIdeal (PresentedWeyl L m)),
87     IsInvolutive
88       (Module.annihilator (SymbolRing L m)
89         (OrderAssociatedGradedModule L I)).radical
90 
91 /-- The same statement written through the order initial ideal, which the
92 repository proves is exactly that annihilator. -/
93 def WeylOrderInitialRadicalInvolutivity : Prop :=
94   ∀ (L : Type u) [Field L] [CharZero L] (m : ℕ)
95     (I : RightIdeal (PresentedWeyl L m)),
96     IsInvolutive (orderInitialIdeal L I).radical
97 
98 /-- Involutivity of every minimal prime of the order initial ideal, for an
99 arbitrary right ideal of an arbitrary Weyl algebra over an arbitrary
100 characteristic-zero field. -/
101 def RightWeylMinimalPrimeInvolutivity : Prop :=
102   ∀ (L : Type u) [Field L] [CharZero L] (m : ℕ)
103     (I : RightIdeal (PresentedWeyl L m)),
104     ∀ P ∈ (orderInitialIdeal L I).minimalPrimes, IsInvolutive P
105 
106 /-- The annihilator form and the initial-ideal form of the citation are the
107 same proposition. -/
108 theorem weylOrderInitialRadicalInvolutivity_iff_associatedGraded :
109     WeylOrderInitialRadicalInvolutivity.{u} ↔
110       WeylAssociatedGradedRadicalInvolutivity.{u} := by
111   constructor
112   · intro h L _ _ m I
113     rw [annihilator_orderAssociatedGradedModule]
114     exact h L m I
115   · intro h L _ _ m I
116     have := h L m I
117     rwa [annihilator_orderAssociatedGradedModule] at this
118 
119 theorem weylOrderInitialRadicalInvolutivity_of_associatedGraded
120     (h : WeylAssociatedGradedRadicalInvolutivity.{u}) :
121     WeylOrderInitialRadicalInvolutivity.{u} :=
122   weylOrderInitialRadicalInvolutivity_iff_associatedGraded.mpr h
123 
124 /-- Descent from the radical to its minimal primes.  This is the step that
125 removes the mismatch between the citation and the project interface. -/
126 theorem rightWeylMinimalPrimeInvolutivity_of_radical
127     (h : WeylOrderInitialRadicalInvolutivity.{u}) :
128     RightWeylMinimalPrimeInvolutivity.{u} := by
129   intro L _ _ m I P hP
130   exact minimalPrimes_isInvolutive_of_radical_isInvolutive_viaLocalization
131     (orderInitialIdeal L I) (h L m I) P hP
132 
133 /-- The canonical right ideal `dA + x₀^N dA` is one right ideal among all of
134 them, so the generic statement specializes to the lane-B target.  Neither
135 `0 < N` nor `IsPBWMonicAt` is used. -/
136 theorem canonicalMinimalPrimeInvolutivityOverFields_of_rightWeyl
137     (h : RightWeylMinimalPrimeInvolutivity.{u}) :
138     CanonicalMinimalPrimeInvolutivityOverFields.{u} := by
139   intro L _ _ n N d _ _ P hP
140   exact h L (n + 1) _ P hP
141 
142 /-- Lane B in one step: residue-extension symbol control from the cited
143 Gabber theorem for arbitrary right ideals over arbitrary characteristic-zero
144 fields. -/
145 theorem canonicalResidueExtensionSymbolControl_of_associatedGradedRadical
146     (h : WeylAssociatedGradedRadicalInvolutivity.{u}) :
147     CanonicalResidueExtensionSymbolControl.{u} :=
148   canonicalResidueExtensionSymbolControl_of_minimalPrimeInvolutivity
149     (canonicalMinimalPrimeInvolutivityOverFields_of_rightWeyl
150       (rightWeylMinimalPrimeInvolutivity_of_radical
151         (weylOrderInitialRadicalInvolutivity_of_associatedGraded h)))
152 
153 #print axioms WeylAssociatedGradedRadicalInvolutivity
154 #print axioms WeylOrderInitialRadicalInvolutivity
155 #print axioms RightWeylMinimalPrimeInvolutivity
156 #print axioms weylOrderInitialRadicalInvolutivity_iff_associatedGraded
157 #print axioms weylOrderInitialRadicalInvolutivity_of_associatedGraded
158 #print axioms rightWeylMinimalPrimeInvolutivity_of_radical
159 #print axioms canonicalMinimalPrimeInvolutivityOverFields_of_rightWeyl
160 #print axioms canonicalResidueExtensionSymbolControl_of_associatedGradedRadical
161 
162 end
163 
164 end Stafford38.Characteristic.CanonicalGabberInvolutivityInterface
165